Categories
Home
Asthma General Questions
Asthma Medicine Questions
Asthma Symptoms Questions
Asthma Treatment Questions
Asthma Allergy Questions
Asthma Attack Questions
Child Asthma Questions
Site Map
 
 
   
Different doctors, different advice

Question:
My son seems to get asthma attacks frequently, about once a month, lasting a week each time. I try to keep the house clean, wash the sheets and clothes with hot water, reduce the amount of processed food we eat, etc etc. But sometimes I feel so much at my wits' end because despite my efforts, he's still coming down with these attacks, particularly when he catches a cold or the flu (and kids do that so often). Not to mention that I feel a certain amount of guilt already (I myself had been diagnosed as suffering from "asthmatic bronchitis" when I was 18 and I get asthmatic attacks 3-5 times a year) at having, maybe, "passed" him the disease. How long does it take before one gets the "hang" of managing asthma? Previously I never took any significant interest in the subject of asthma because I only wheezed when I caught the flu. Other times I'm fine. For years, too, doctors told me I didn't have asthma, I had "asthmatic bronchitis", which they insisted was not asthma. But now that my son is suffering from asthma, I'm reading all I can about the subject, everything from treatment to prevention. What confuses me, however, is how trained doctors, with regard to how one should manage the disease, can differ in opinion so greatly. It doesn't help, either, that my son has not gained weight since March this year, and we think it's because of his asthma. another question, does the medication my son is taking cause personality "changes"? Ever since June, when he started his medication, his nursery school teachers say he's been more active but less co-operative and more aggressive. His teacher actually said "He's like a totally different boy!"


Answer:
Asthma treatment has changed recently, your GP is out of date. Go with the specialist. GPs don't have time to be experts in all the different diseases they treat. Your GP should have consulted with your specialist before prescribing a different treatment. Its best to go direct to an asthma doctor for moderate or severe asthma. Nebulizers are no longer necessary, MDI (metered dose inhalers) are just as good for most patients, and more convenient, according to new asthma guidelines. Use a spacer, like an AeroChamber. If necessary the AeroChamber with Mask spacer could be used. Your specialist should be able to give you an 'Action Plan' to adjust medication if symptoms get worse, without actually seeing him. It will be easier when your child is a little older and use a Peak Flow Meter to measure lung capacity at home. In the US, we use 1997 Expert Panel Report--Asthma Guidelines. Since you are in Singapore, I suggest the GINA (Global Initiative for Asthma) Guidelines. You can download the Doctor's Pocket Guide at www.ginasthma.com/gina/pocket.html These guidelines were written with input from a doctor from Singapore; W. C. Tan, MD There is also a patients version available, to update yourself on treatment. Also see http://www.ama-assn.org/special/asthma/treatmnt/treatmnt.htm Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Asthma National Asthma Education and Prevention Program Expert Panel Report II, National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute February 1997 Asthma Management and Prevention (A Pocket Guide for Physicians and Nurses) GINA 1995 Another inhaler to consider is Intal, not as strong as Flixotide but less side effects. Intal has virtually no side effects and is used for mild asthma. Atrovent probably not appropriate, in the US it is usually used for COPD rather than asthma. I'm not completely happy with the high Ventolin use. 3 puffs Ventolin every 4 hr seems like a lot for 2 weeks, Hopefully this drug use will reduce down after he gets over the exacerbation. If you learn more about asthma, how to recognize symptoms, and use a peak flow meter, you should be able to start adjusting the dose of asthma drugs yourself. A Pediatric peak flow meter is available, a mini-Wright to be used at home. The new guidelines are that Ventolin should only be use 'as needed', not on a continuous basis. The main asthma long term control drug is an anti-inflammatory, since asthma is an inflammation of the bronchial tubes; either Intal for mild cases, or inhaled stereoids like Flixotide for moderate or severe asthma. The personality change could due to better control of asthma giving him more energy. Also Ventolin in high doses can be a stimulant.



Submit your comment or answer


 
| Home | Asthma General Questions | Asthma Medicine Questions | Asthma Symptoms Questions | Asthma Treatment Questions | Asthma Allergy Questions | Asthma Attack Questions | Child Asthma Questions | Site Map |
Privacy Policy